Many tax systems give small businesses a choice: pay VAT at a low flat rate on turnover without deducting the VAT paid to suppliers, or register for standard VAT at a higher rate and deduct input tax. The difference between the two is money that either stays in the business or goes to the tax authority. Here is how the logic works and how to calculate which option suits your company.
Thresholds, rates and lock-in rules differ by country and change regularly. Check the current rules in your jurisdiction before choosing.
Two ways to pay VAT
- Flat rate. A low percentage of turnover, no deduction of input VAT. Simple to run and usually available only below a turnover threshold.
- Standard rate. A higher rate on sales, minus the VAT paid on purchases from VAT-registered suppliers. More paperwork, but input tax is recovered.
- Losing a small-business exemption usually happens from a set date after a threshold is crossed. Sales made before that date are not affected.
The key difference is input deduction
Under the flat rate a company pays tax on all its turnover and cannot reduce it by the VAT paid to suppliers. Under the standard rate the tax is higher, but input VAT on purchases from registered suppliers is deducted. So the choice comes down to one ratio: what share of revenue consists of purchases that carry VAT.
Take revenue net of VAT. Under a 5% flat rate you pay 5% of revenue. Under a 20% standard rate you pay 20% of revenue minus 20% of purchases with VAT. The two are equal when purchases with VAT reach 75% of revenue (0.15 / 0.20). Below that line the flat rate wins, above it the standard rate does.
Two examples
| Service company | Wholesale trader | |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue net of VAT | $10M | $10M |
| Purchases from VAT-registered suppliers | $1.5M | $8.5M |
| VAT at a 5% flat rate | $0.5M | $0.5M |
| VAT at a 20% standard rate | 2.0 - 0.3 = $1.7M | 2.0 - 1.7 = $0.3M |
| Better option | flat rate, saves $1.2M | standard rate, saves $0.2M |
A service company spends mostly on salaries, freelancers and rent, which carry little or no input VAT. A wholesaler with a markup of around 18% buys almost everything from registered suppliers, and the deduction outweighs the higher rate. The examples are illustrative.
What else affects the choice
- Who your customers are. For VAT-registered customers the rate is neutral: they deduct exactly the tax they paid you, so only your own burden matters. For consumers and unregistered businesses VAT is part of the price: under the standard rate you either raise prices or give up margin.
- Lock-in periods. Some schemes require you to stay on the chosen option for several years. Check this before your first return.
- Investment plans. A large equipment purchase or construction project with VAT makes the standard rate more attractive, because the input tax is recovered.
- Paperwork. Standard VAT means tax invoices, purchase and sales ledgers, regular returns and supplier checks.
- Prices in contracts. Check whether prices are stated inclusive or exclusive of VAT. That decides whether you add the tax on top or pay it from your margin.
The share of purchases with VAT can differ several-fold between two companies in the same industry, depending on suppliers, rent and payroll. The calculation takes an hour, while the choice may last for years.
How to calculate it for your company
Take revenue net of VAT for the last 12 months and the forecast for next year.
Isolate purchases from VAT-registered suppliers: goods, materials, commercial rent, services, leasing. Payroll, freelancers and unregistered suppliers carry no input VAT.
Divide purchases with VAT by revenue and compare the result with the break-even point for your country's rates.
Check which customers are VAT-registered and whether the tax can be passed on in the price.
Build VAT into the model and budget from the month the obligation starts, not for the whole year.
Frequently asked questions
If turnover crosses the threshold mid-year, is VAT due for the whole year?
Usually not. The obligation typically starts from a set date after the threshold is crossed, and earlier sales are not affected. Check the exact rule in your jurisdiction.
How do I find the break-even point for my rates?
Divide the difference between the standard and flat rates by the standard rate. With 20% and 5% that is 75%.
Is the flat rate always better for a service business?
Usually yes, because services carry little input VAT. Exceptions are businesses with large equipment purchases or expensive subcontracting from VAT-registered suppliers.
Can I switch later?
It depends on the scheme. Some allow switching at any time, others impose a minimum period. Check before the first return.
We will calculate your VAT option
We analyse your purchases, customers and contracts, compare the options on your numbers and build VAT into your financial model and prices so the tax does not eat your margin.